BetrayStories

The Stranger at the Bar Who Knew Her Too

2 min read · Anonymous · Premium

2 min read · Premium

The thing about a quiet Tuesday at a neighborhood bar is that you let your guard down. There's no music loud enough to hide behind, no crowd to disappear into. Just a row of stools, a tired bartender, and whoever happens to be sitting two seats away.

His name was Theo. We got to talking the way strangers do when there's a game on the corner television and neither of you cares who wins. He bought a round. I bought the next. By the second beer we'd done the usual map of a small life, where do you work, where'd you grow up, and somewhere in there we landed on people we might both know.

This story continues…

$5.99 50% OFF → $2.99/mo · cancel anytime

Read next

Shocking Discovery
Premium

The Poem Wasn't for Me

4 min

I was unpacking the first boxes in our new place when I borrowed the iPod on his speaker dock for some music. It kept chiming. I shouldn't have looked. I'm so glad I did.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

The Dream That Knew Before I Did

4 min

I woke at 4 a.m. certain of something I had no proof of. By breakfast I had the proof, and I wished I'd never gone looking.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Free

The Parrot Started Saying Her Name

5 min

My husband got jumpy whenever I came home early. I never found a single text or receipt. The thing that finally told me the truth had feathers.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

Home From Drill Eight Hours Early

4 min

Range qualifications got scrubbed, so I drove home a day ahead of schedule. I didn't need to find a text. The apartment told me everything before she did.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

What the Car Saw in the Dark

2 min

A scratch in a parking lot sent me looking for footage. The cameras had recorded something else entirely, and I couldn't unsee it.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

The Wedding Videographer Caught More Than the First Dance

4 min

We sat down to relive the happiest night of our lives. By the end of the film, my best friend's whole world had quietly ended in the background of it.

Read story →

New stories, every week

Get the most gripping new betrayal and infidelity stories delivered to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

We’ll only email you new stories. Your address is never shared.