BetrayStories

I Whispered Our Secret to the Wrong Twin in the Dark

4 min read · Anonymous · Premium

4 min read · Premium

There are some things you can never take back out of the air, and I learned that in a dark room with my hand on the wrong man's shoulder.

I should start with the fact that my husband had a twin. Not a cousin who looked like him, not a brother people confused at weddings — an identical twin, Gallagher, who shared his face, his voice, the same slow way of rubbing the back of his neck when he was thinking. When I married into that family I was told the famous joke a hundred times: even their mother got it wrong on the phone. I laughed every time. I had no idea I'd build my whole secret life on the seam between two men who were born from the same hour.

This story continues…

$5.99 50% OFF → $2.99/mo · cancel anytime

Read next

Shocking Discovery
Premium

What the Car Saw in the Dark

2 min

A scratch in a parking lot sent me looking for footage. The cameras had recorded something else entirely, and I couldn't unsee it.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

My Four-Year-Old Told Me About the Wrestling Game

4 min

I came home from a work trip exhausted and grateful. Then my son, half asleep, asked me a question I will never stop hearing.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

The Voicemail He Never Knew He Left

4 min

He slid his phone into his pocket and walked into the hotel with her. Somewhere in the dark of that pocket, a number was dialing home.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

The Dream That Knew Before I Did

4 min

I woke at 4 a.m. certain of something I had no proof of. By breakfast I had the proof, and I wished I'd never gone looking.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

The Stranger at the Bar Who Knew Her Too

2 min

A friendly chat with a stranger over two beers turns into the kind of confession that costs you a friendship before you even finish your drink.

Read story →
Shocking Discovery
Premium

The Board He Thought No One Else Would Ever See

4 min

I just wanted ideas for the guest bathroom. Instead I clicked on my own husband's profile and found a wedding being planned without me.

Read story →

New stories, every week

Get the most gripping new betrayal and infidelity stories delivered to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

We’ll only email you new stories. Your address is never shared.